Testimony of Denise Forte on FY23 Labor, Health and Human Services, Education and Related Agencies Appropriations Bill
Written Testimony for the Record
On behalf of Denise Forte
The Education Trust
Before the House Appropriations Subcommittee on Labor, Health and Human Services, Education and Related Agencies
On behalf of The Education Trust, a national nonprofit that works to close opportunity gaps that disproportionately affect students of color and students from low-income families, thank you for the opportunity to present testimony on the Fiscal Year 2023 (FY23) Labor, Health and Human Services, Education, and Related Agencies (L-HHS-ED) Appropriations bill. We request that the L-HHS-ED bill make substantial investments in excess of prior, cap-limited years to ensure that essential education programs have the resources they need to ensure the greatest impact for students of color and students from low-income communities.
While there are many programs under your jurisdiction that are critical to advancing equity, in FY23, The Education Trust is focused on the following:
- Strengthening the Pell Grant program by increasing the maximum award to keep pace with inflation, at a minimum, and ideally, doubling the maximum award.
- Supporting teachers and school leaders by including funding and language supporting the following:
- ESSA (Every Student Succeeds Act) Title I-A ($18.54 billion);
- Incentives for states and localities to evaluate their education funding formulas and policies and implement equitable reforms ($100 million);
- ESSA Title II-A ($3 billion);
- the Teacher and School Leader Incentive Program (TSLIP) ($200 million);
- the Supporting Effective Educator Development Program (SEED) ($140 million);
- HEA (Higher Education Act) Title II’s Teacher Quality Partnership (TQP) grants ($300 million); and
- restoring funding to the School Leader Recruitment and Support Program (SLRSP) ($40 million).
- Maintain FY22 omnibus report language increasing equity in advanced coursework.
- Enabling enhanced preparation for teaching candidates at Historically Black Colleges and Universities (HBCUs) and Minority-Serving Institutions (MSIs) by allocating at least $40 million in funding for the Augustus F. Hawkins Centers of Excellence Grant program.
- Developing and strengthening evidence-based student success programs by allocating $110 million in funding for the Post Secondary Student Success Grant program.
- Supporting student parents by allocating $500 million in funding for the Child Care Access Means Parents in School (CCAMPIS) program.
We urge increased support by the Committee for these critical programs to help meet the needs of students of color and students from low-income communities.
Strengthening the Pell Grant Program
The Pell Grant program is the cornerstone of federal financial aid. The program benefits over 7 million students annually and continues to serve as the primary federal investment designed to allow students from low-income backgrounds to access higher education. Over one-third of White students, two-thirds of Black students, and half of Latino students rely on Pell Grants every year. 1 Pell Grant dollars are well-targeted to those in need: 83 percent of Pell recipients come from families with annual incomes at or below $40,000, including 44 percent with annual family incomes at or below $15,000. 2
Increase the Maximum Award
The maximum Pell Grant award has failed to keep pace with the rapidly rising cost of college over the past several decades. In 1980, the maximum Pell Grant award covered 77 percent of the cost of attendance at a public university. Today, it covers just over 28 percent, the lowest portion in over 40 years. Bold action must be taken to halt and reverse this damaging trend.
We are appreciative of previous increases to the maximum award in prior appropriations bills, including the $400 increase in the Fiscal Year 2022 (FY22) omnibus, and we respectfully request that you continue to annually increase the maximum award amount. It is also worth noting that nearly 1,200 organizations have gone on record supporting the doubling of the Pell Grant.
In FY23, Congress should, at minimum, increase the maximum award upward from $6,895 to keep pace with inflation. It is also time for Congress to implement an ambitious plan to reverse the downward trend of Pell’s purchasing power through doubling the maximum award, including expanding the mandatory funding stream, ensuring that the maximum Pell award covers at least half of the cost of attendance at a public four-year institution.
Supporting Students, Teachers, and School Leaders
Increase funding for ESSA’s Title I-A; ESSA’s Title II-A (Supporting Effective Instruction); the Teacher and School Leader Incentive Program (TSLIP), the Supporting Effective Educator Development (SEED) program, HEA’s Title II Teacher Quality Partnership (TQP) grants; incentivize states and localities to evaluate their education funding formulas and policies and implement equitable reforms; and maintain FY22 report language supporting increasing equity in advanced coursework.
The Education Trust, building on the prior $1 billion funding increase for Title I in the FY22 omnibus, supports another $1 billion funding increase in FY23 budget for ESSA’s Title I-A program. However, it is important to note that most public education funding is distributed via state and local formulas. Therefore, any federal funding increases of this size should be accompanied by levers that encourage states and districts to address the inequities inherent in those formulas. This is a tremendous opportunity to spark systemic reform of the status quo that sends $23 billion more to predominantly White school districts than predominantly non-White school districts. We urge the committee to think boldly about how make the overall education funding system more equitable, including inserting report language to that effect, and to include the $100 million designated for this purpose within the Biden-Harris administration’s FY23 budget request in the L-HHS-ED Appropriations bill.
Furthermore, research and experience show the powerful impact that teachers and school leaders have on student learning. ESSA’s Title II-A program provides grants to states and districts that can be used to invest in and develop educators. These funds can be used to, among other things, address inequities in access to effective teachers and school leaders, provide professional development, and improve teacher recruitment and retention. States and districts can also apply for additional competitive grant dollars for programs like TSLIP and SEED, which are targeted at specific, evidence-based strategies for improving teacher and school leader effectiveness and increasing educator diversity. Additionally, HEA’s Title II TQP grants, awarded to partnerships between high-need districts and teacher preparation programs at institutions of higher education, can be used to recruit underrepresented populations to the teaching profession. As Ed Trust’s work continues to demonstrate the positive impact that diverse teachers and school leaders of color can have on the academic achievement of both students of color and White students, we remain supportive of federal dollars to increase and bolster the diversity of the educator pipeline.
Finally, research shows that Black, Latino and Native students, students with disabilities, and students from low-income families are underrepresented in advanced programs and courses (gifted and talented, advanced placement, international baccalaureate, honors courses, dual enrollment, etc.). We the inclusion of report language included in the FY22 omnibus that noted that funds under ESEA (Elementary and Secondary Education Act) may be used to implement open enrollment, automatic enrollment, and/ or universal screening practices; to increase course access and success; to provide coaching and training for educators; to purchase materials; and/or cover exam fees for underrepresented students. The language also encouraged the Department to resume collecting data on passing rates for all Advanced Placement subject areas.
Considering the nationwide attention to the need to invest in educators, especially as schools work to counteract the negative impacts of the COVID-19 pandemic, Congress appropriated increases for most of these programs in FY22: $2.17B for the Title II-A grant, $85M for the SEED program, and $59.09M for HEA’s Title II TQP grants, but unfortunately cut TSLIP by $27M down from $200M in FY21.
At a minimum, in FY23, Congress should: increase Title I-A; allocate $100M to incentivize states and localities to evaluate their education funding formulas and policies and implement equitable reforms; increase Title II-A, TSLIP, SEED, and TQP beyond FY22 levels: $18.54B, $3B, $200M, $140M, and $300M, respectively, and maintain report language supporting increasing equity in advanced coursework.
Restore Funding for the School Leader Recruitment and Support Program
Landmark research funded by the Wallace Foundation has found “virtually no documented instances of troubled schools being turned around without intervention by a powerful leader,” and the School Leader Recruitment and Support Program is the only federal program specifically focused on investing in evidence-based, locally driven strategies to strengthen school leadership in high-need schools. A seven-year study , concluded in 2019, of school districts that created pipelines to develop school leaders saw increasing gains in student achievement over time, showing how a sustained initiative can demonstrate positive effects on student learning.
There is still a great deal of work to do, especially when it comes to identifying and efficiently preparing effective turnaround leaders, as well as sustainably supporting them to accelerate academic achievement, close gaps, and maintain improvement over time for all students and in every community. Developing strong leaders to build essential relationships with students and the communities they operate in is a fundamental necessity to help students finish the learning currently unfinished due to the COVID-19 pandemic. The SLRSP is a key lever for seeding the next generation of effective school leader development programs, promoting equity, advancing ongoing innovation, and sharing innovative lessons on transformational leadership with the broader field.
In FY23, Congress should restore funding for the School Leader Recruitment and Support Program to $40M, the amount included in the FY23 President’s Budget and a moderate increase from what was included in FY22 Senate Labor-HHS-ED Appropriations bill.
Increase funding for the Augustus F. Hawkins Centers of Excellence Grant Program
Research has shown that students of color benefit tremendously from having teachers of color, particularly one of the same racial background: they are less likely to be chronically absent or suspended from school , more likely to be recommended for gifted and talented programs, and low-income Black students who have a Black teacher for at least one year in elementary school are less likely to drop out of high school and more likely to consider college. And while students of color make up the majority of students in public schools, the diversity gap for teachers of color still exists across every state. For example, Virginia has taken steps to address their diversity gap by using their ARPA (American Rescue Plan Act) funds to “provid[e] ongoing support to recruit, hire, and retain a diverse school staff” including programs to induct and mentor new teachers of color and targeted student loan assistance programs for pre-service and in-service teachers of color.
The nationwide impact of HBCUs, MSIs, Hispanic-Serving Institutions (HSIs), and Tribal Colleges and Universities (TCUs) on producing teachers of color cannot be overstated. HBCUs, TCUs, and MSIs, collectively, award only 11% of the nation’s bachelor’s degrees in education, yet they produce more than 50% of the bachelor’s degrees earned in education by Hispanic, Native Hawaiian and Pacific Islander students. 3 HBCUs graduate approximately 50% of the nation’s African American teachers with bachelor’s degrees. 4 HSIs prepare 90% of Hispanic teachers, and along with other MSIs, constitute a vital pipeline to maintain diversity among our nation’s teachers. 5
Considering the importance of these institutions, the increased needs they experience as result of graduating an outsized portion of the nation’s teachers of color, and the exacerbated nature of the current shortage of teachers of color due to the COVID-19 pandemic, we request that Congress build on the highly appreciated $8M investment made in the Augustus F. Hawkins Centers of Excellence grant program in the FY22 omnibus. Increasing Congress’ investment would provide critical funding to these key institutions to provide increased and enhanced clinical experience and increased financial aid to prospective teachers of color, who face higher burdens in college access and affordability than their White peers. Finally, the FY23 President’s Budget proposal recommended continued and additional funding for the program, and a recent House Dear Colleague letter in support of increasing funding to the program to $40 million garnered 34 signatures.
In FY23, Congress should fund the Augustus F. Hawkins Centers of Excellence Grant Program at $40M.
Supporting College Students
Fund the Post Secondary Student Success Grant Program
Despite the gains made in high school graduation rates over the past several decades, the fact remains that only six in ten students earn a college degree after six years of undergraduate study, and Black and Hispanic individuals have a lower rate of degree attainment than their White and Asian-American peers. The COVID-19 pandemic has exacerbated this problem: college enrollment has declined by 5.1 percent across the board since spring of 2020. These challenges present the possibility of long-term negative effects on students, their families, state and national economies, and the country.
Congress, with the support of 14 organizations including Ed Trust, included a $5 million dollar investment in Post Secondary Student Success Grants in the FY22 omnibus. That is a positive development that we look forward to helping the Department implement, but we will need much more to reverse these damaging trends. Prior proposals from the Biden administration and both chambers of Congress understood the size and scope of the problem of low college completion rates, and we hope the committee will revisit those when deciding how much to invest moving forward. The FY23 President’s Budget proposal included a request for $110M for this concept, as did a recent House Dear Colleague letter that garnered 26 signatures. W e support that funding level for this appropriations cycle.
In FY23, Congress should fund the Post Secondary Student Success Grant Program at $110M.
Fund the Child Care Access Means Parents in School (CCAMPIS) Program
Over 20 percent of undergraduate students are parents of dependent children, and within that cohort, 1.7 million are single mothers. As detailed further in this letter from 51 organizations in support of this funding ask, including Ed Trust, increasing the funding for CCAMPIS would provide child care support for approximately 100,000 more student parents, giving them access to the child care services they need to get to and through college. This population is increasing year after year, and in a recent survey of over 20,000 student parents, 70 percent indicated their current childcare provider was unaffordable. Furthermore, an upcoming report from Ed Trust will show that on average, a student parent would need to work anywhere from 30 to 90 hours a week to cover child care and tuition costs at a public college or university.
It is essential that Congress scale up the only program specifically designed to deliver on-campus child care to Pell-eligible student parents, which would dramatically enhance their chances of achieving educational success and financial stability.
In FY23, Congress should fund the Child Care Access Means Parents in School (CCAMPIS) Program at $500M.
Thank you for the opportunity to submit testimony. The Education Trust looks forward to working with Congress to allocate federal funds in a way that addresses the critical equity gaps that our nation’s students from low-income backgrounds and students of color continue to face. We are happy to respond to any questions or concerns that you may have on these topics.
The Education Trust
- Congressional Budget Office (CBO), January 2017 baseline projections for the Pell Grant program, http://bit.ly/2mLy0nk, Table 2; and Ed Trust calculation NPSAS:12 using PowerStats.
- Analysis of Federal Pell Grant Program Annual Data Report, available at ed.gov/finaid/prof/resources/data/pell-data.html.
- Branch Alliance for Educator Diversity, “Homepage,” available at educatordiversity.org/.
- Jacqueline Jordan Irvine and Leslie T. Fenwick, “Teachers and Teaching for the New Millennium: The Role of HBCUs,” The Journal of Negro Education 80 (3) (2011): 197–208, available at jstor.org/stable/41341128; National Association for Equal Opportunity in Higher Education: Comments to the Department of Education proposed rule changes for teacher preparation programs available at: nafeonation.org/wp-content/uploads/2015/01/NADEC_Teacher_Prep_Regulations_Discussion_Document_2-2-15__.pdf .
- Hispanic Association of Colleges and Universities, “Teacher Diversity,” hacuadvocates.net/teacherdiversity?1.